The newest and best mascaras are frequently discussed, but what about the worst ones that we should avoid? Since there are thousands of mascara tubes available, I believe we should be given some sort of advice on what other people have found to be ineffective. In this manner, we will be prepared if we decide to test out bad mascaras for ourselves. Girls ought to support one another, don’t they? Having said that, check out these eight mascaras with the lowest ratings to see if your worst mascara was included!
1. Maybelline Great Lash
I am aware that some of you women will be shocked to see this mascara on the list of the worst mascaras. Although it has hordes of fans and is considered a classic, not everyone seems to agree. This mascara has been characterized by users as smudgy, flaky, and challenging to remove. Additionally, it has been criticized for drying out too quickly, so if you’re new to Great Lash, consider these user reviews before making a purchase!
On the plus side, keep in mind that Great Lash is an affordable choice that has been popular since the 1970s if you do choose to give it a try. It is frequently praised for its timeless pink-and-green packaging and for giving people who don’t want dramatic volume a natural-looking appearance. But as some beauty enthusiasts point out, it might fall short of the standards set by more recent, sophisticated formulas. It may not be the mascara for the contemporary beauty expert, but for a tried-and-true product, its place in the beauty hall of fame is assured.
2. NYX Faux Lashes Boudoir
With their Faux Lashes Boudoir mascara, NYX is another well-known brand that won the award for worst mascara. Unfortunately, users disagree with the product description, which claims that the formula is infused with fibers to lengthen lashes and is excellent for bottom lashes. Women complained that this mascara was runny, clumpy, and prone to smudging. Since NYX isn’t particularly well-known for its mascaras, if you’ve never heard of the brand before, try their lip and eye shadow products—they’re far superior!
3. Benefit BADgal Lash
It may surprise you to find Benefit’s BADgal Lash on this list of the worst mascaras, but it is! While BADgal Lash has a large fan base, there are also many critics. BADgal Lash has been described as excessively wet, smudgy, natural-looking, and clumpy. BADgal has a lot of fans, so this one might be worth a shot, but since it’s on the expensive side at $19.00, proceed with caution!
Benefit BADgal Lash is a mascara that has received a lot of attention due to its high price point of $19.00. However, many customers have complained that the mascara is too wet, smudgy, and clumpy, making it difficult to use. Furthermore, some customers found the results to be too natural-looking for their tastes. Despite its popularity, Benefit BADgal Lash has made the list of the worst mascaras to avoid. Before making a purchase, read customer reviews and consider the possible drawbacks of this expensive mascara.
4. Wet N Wild MegaPlump
A mascara that claims to provide up to 5x volume cannot be rated low, right? Wet n Wild’s MegaPlump appeared to be a promising product at under $5.00, but based on the product’s poor reviews, it’s hardly worth the low price! MegaPlump was described as clumpy, thin, flaky, and drying, all of which are undesirable qualities in mascara! Nobody said anything good about this mascara, so you’re probably not missing out if you skip it!
It’s disappointing when a mascara doesn’t live up to its bold claims. Unfortunately, MegaPlump is one of these products. Users reported messy clumps, an unexpectedly thin formula, and irritating flakes, which can ruin an otherwise perfect makeup day. Worse, it feels dry, leaving lashes looking frazzled rather than lush. Given the numerous negative reviews and a lack of redeeming qualities, it appears that this product is best left on the shelf. Save your money for a mascara that actually enhances your lashes rather than causing irritation. Trust the reviews and avoid this underwhelming find!
5. Revlon DoubleTwist
Unfortunately, Revlon’s DoubleTwist is yet another bad mascara. This mascara received positive feedback for its lengthening and separating properties. However, an overwhelming number of negative reviews landed it on this mascara hit list! Smudging, flaking, and an ineffective brush design were all to blame for its poor performance.
Although the packaging appears promising, and the concept of a double brush design appears novel, many users found the application disappointing. The brush is difficult to use, clumping fuller lashes rather than defining them. Furthermore, the formula appears to be unreliable, with flaking occurring only hours after application. While it has fans who like the longer lash effect, the frequent need for touch-ups makes it more trouble than it’s worth for many. Consumers looking for a reliable mascara that can be worn confidently throughout the day may want to consider alternatives. Revlon DoubleTwist is still controversial among mascara fans.
6. Stila Forever Your Curl Memory
Stila may be the queen of crème blushes and lip glazes, but Forever Your Curl ended up being one of the worst mascaras. Forever Your Curl claimed it would be long-lasting and instantly curl lashes, but the lack of rave reviews suggests otherwise! Some ladies praised it for its definition and lengthening properties, but it was also described as runny, smudgy, and flaky.
The formula’s tendency to be inconsistent was a source of disappointment, in addition to its poor performance. Users frequently reported clumping issues, and despite claims of durability, the reality was far from it. Furthermore, the brush design didn’t help matters; it appeared to lack the precision required for a smooth application, making it difficult to achieve the desired curl effect. For those looking for a dependable daily mascara, this product fell short, leaving lashes looking lackluster rather than luxurious. Overall, despite a few redeeming qualities, it failed to deliver.
7. Rimmel Glam Eyes Day2Night
Rimmel is responsible for the following low-rated mascara. The Glam Eyes Day2Night mascara includes two cool caps for lengthening and volume. While the tube appears to be capable of double duty, users described this mascara as thin, messy, and lacking in fullness and length. Rimmel makes some good mascaras; too bad this one wasn’t very effective!
8. Maybelline Define-a-Lash Waterproof
We had to include a waterproof formula of bad mascara on this list, and Define-a-lash was the unfortunate choice! This mascara won Allure’s Beauty Editors’ Choice award but received poor reviews. Mascara lovers complained that the formula was dry, difficult to remove, and clumped quickly after application. Maybelline has tons of other winning formulas, so don’t be discouraged if this one fails you!
Have you ever used any of these terrible mascaras? I’m pretty obsessed with mascara, so I’ve used some of the bad ones, but I’ve also used a lot of good ones! What is the worst mascara you have ever used? Is there a feature of a mascara that turns you off?
The Mascara Faq’s
What makes a mascara ‘bad’?
Some of the mascaras that are often cited as being among the “worst” or disappointing are the YSL Baby Doll mascara because of its propensity to smudge and cause raccoon eyes, especially on oily skin; the Marc Jacobs Velvet Noir mascara because of its wet, clumpy formula; and the Giorgio Armani Eccentrico mascara because of its uneven application and clumps. Pixi Lower Lash Mascara’s ineffective wand, Benefit BadGal Lash, and Benefit They’re Real mascara—both of which are infamous for smudging—are other commonly mentioned underwhelming products.
Can thick or clumpy mascara be fixed?
Sometimes, the formula can be thinned by adding a few drops of saline solution. However, if the mascara is excessively clumpy, it may be more effective to replace it.
Can expired mascara be harmful?
Certainly, expired mascara may contain bacteria that could result in eye infections. It is imperative to verify the expiration date of mascara and refrain from using it after that date.
Is waterproof mascara bad for my lashes?
While waterproof mascara is not necessarily detrimental, it can be more difficult to remove and may result in lash loss if not done so gently.
How can I tell if a mascara is bad before I buy it?
In the event that the product fails to meet your expectations, you may consult reviews, examine the ingredients for potential irritants, and determine whether the brand has a return policy.
Can a mascara be bad for my eye health?
It is true that mascaras containing harmful chemicals or allergens can result in eye irritation, infections, or allergic reactions. Always verify the ingredients and, whenever feasible, conduct a patch test.
What should I do if a mascara irritates my eyes?
Should a mascara cause irritation to your eyes, discontinue its use immediately. In the event that irritation persists, it is also possible to rinse your eyes with water and seek the advice of an eye doctor.
Are there any ingredients in mascara I should avoid?
It is advisable to steer clear of mascaras that contain synthetic dyes, sulfates, phthalates, or parabens, particularly if you have sensitive skin or eyes.
How do I properly test a mascara?
Test the mascara on your hand to observe its color and consistency whenever feasible. Testers are available at certain retailers; however, it is crucial to avoid applying them directly to your eyes for hygiene reasons.
Why do some mascaras flake and how can I prevent this?
Mascaras may develop flaking when they are old, dry, or of inferior quality. To prevent this, apply your mascara in thin, even layers and ensure that it is fresh.
How often should I replace my mascara?
To prevent potential eye infections and maintain performance, it is advised to replace your mascara every 3 to 6 months.
